Spotting the Study Design

We can work the type of study by looking at three issues:

Assigning exposures

Will you “assign” exposures?

If you assign exposure—which might be an intervention, like an antidepressant, a placebo, or a therapy, for example—you are doing an experimental (intervention before observation) study.

Observational (no intervention involved)

Experimental designs

Will there be a control group? Controlled study.

Will there be an active comparator or placebo?

Some trials use an active comparator, and we call it active comparator trial. if you want to you a placebo, your study design is a placebo-control trial.

will the allocation be random?

yes > randomised

no > non-randomised/quasi-experimental

Will the allocation be swapped from time to time? Yes -> cross-over, No -> parallel

Who will know about the allocation of the treatment?

Everyone -> open-label

All except patients > single-blinded

Neither patients nor assessors -> double-blinded

Observational study designs

-> will there be a comparison group?

Yes -> analytical (if you want to test a hypothesis, choose this one)

No -> descriptive study

---

> Analytical study designs

Want to determine the outcome of exposure -> cohort (begins with exposure)

Exposure has occurred in the past and is tracked down till date -> retrospective cohort

Exposure will occur from now onward and will be followed over time -> prospective cohort

Want to determine the (causes of/factors-affecting the) outcome -> case-control (begins with the outcome/cases)

---

Want to determine/identify certain factors in a population at an instance? -> Cross-sectional surveys

comparison group present? -> analytical, otherwise observational

---

Want to determine the prevalence of depression in teachers? -> cross-sectional survey, observational

Want to determine whether physical punishment will lead to poor academic performance in students?

-> either retrospective cohort (punishment received traced till date, better choice, beware bias (students with poor academics more likely to be punished) or case control (academically poor students vs talented students, beware of bias). Don’t choose a prospective cohort, we can not let children be exposed to punishment while conducting research.

Want to test new drug but do not want to harm patients, choose active comparator.

Want to determine the incidence of disease in a particular group, choose prospective cohort. One sample from that group and another comparison group.

Want to determine the risk of cancer in smokers? Choose cohort.

(Point) Prevalence of depression in diabetes? Cross-sectional

10-year prevalence of depression in diabetes? Prospective cohort.

Factors associated with depression in diabetes? Case-control.

CBT versus clinical management? Open label.

ECT efficacy, bright light therapy? Sham comparator.

---

We should finally note that studies can incorporate several design elements. For example, the control arm of a randomised trial may also be used as a cohort study; and we may use the baseline measures of a cohort study as a cross-sectional study.

---

To simply describe a population (PO questions)

descriptive

To quantify the relationship between factors (PICO questions)

analytic.

was the intervention randomly allocated?

Yes?

RCT

No?

Observational study

For observational study the main types will then depend on the timing of the measurement of outcome, so our third question is:

Q3. When were the outcomes determined?

Some time after the exposure or intervention?

cohort study (‘prospective study’)

At the same time as the exposure or intervention?

cross sectional study or survey

Before the exposure was determined?

case-control study (‘retrospective study’ based on recall of the exposure)

For example, if you want to determine the prevalence of depression in teachers, it should be descriptive, observational, cross-sectional study design.

ICD-11 Criteria for Single Episode Depressive Disorder (Depressive Episode) (6A70)

ICD-11 Criteria for Single Episode Depressive Disorder (Depressive Episode) (6A70) Single episode depressive disorder is characterised by the presence or history of one depressive episode when there is no history of prior depressive episodes. A depressive episode is characterised by a period of depressed mood or diminished interest in activities occurring most of the day, nearly every day during a period lasting at least two weeks accompanied by other symptoms such as difficulty concentrating, feelings of worthlessness or excessive or inappropriate guilt, hopelessness, recurrent thoughts of death or suicide, changes in appetite or sleep, psychomotor agitation or retardation, and reduced energy or fatigue. There have never been any prior manic, hypomanic, or mixed episodes, which would indicate the presence of a bipolar disorder. Exclusions: Recurrent depressive disorder (6A71) Adjustment disorder (6B43) Bipolar...

ICD-11 Criteria for Depression (Recurrent Depressive Disorder) 6A71

ICD-11 Criteria for Depression (Recurrent Depressive Disorder) 6A71 Recurrent depressive disorder is characterised by a history or at least two depressive episodes separated by at least several months without significant mood disturbance. A depressive episode is characterised by a period of depressed mood or diminished interest in activities occurring most of the day, nearly every day during a period lasting at least two weeks accompanied by other symptoms such as difficulty concentrating, feelings of worthlessness or excessive or inappropriate guilt, hopelessness, recurrent thoughts of death or suicide, changes in appetite or sleep, psychomotor agitation or retardation, and reduced energy or fatigue. There have never been any prior manic, hypomanic, or mixed episodes, which would indicate the presence of a Bipolar disorder. Inclusions: Seasonal depressive disorder Exclusions: ...

ICD-11 Criteria for Bipolar Type-1 Disorder

ICD-11 Criteria for Bipolar Type-1 Disorder 6A60 Bipolar type I disorder is an episodic mood disorder defined by the occurrence of one or more manic or mixed episodes. A manic episode is an extreme mood state lasting at least one week unless shortened by a treatment intervention characterised by euphoria, irritability, or expansiveness, and by increased activity or a subjective experience of increased energy, accompanied by other characteristic symptoms such as rapid or pressured speech, flight of ideas, increased self-esteem or grandiosity, decreased need for sleep, distractibility, impulsive or reckless behaviour, and rapid changes among different mood states (i.e., mood lability). A mixed episode is characterised by the presence of several prominent manic and several prominent depressive symptoms consistent with those observed in manic episodes and depressive episodes, which either occur simultaneously or alternate very rapidly (from day to day or with...

Search This Blog